Switching Allegiance

It is just over six months now since I decided to migrate from a Gitzo to a Benro tripod; I think enough time has passed for me to be able to give my honest appraisal of using the Benro Mach3 TMA38CL and the accompanying B2 ball head. 

It all started back in May last year when I decided to visit my local woodland/heathland with a view to capturing some of the expected early morning mist. I know the area very well and had my 'go to' places in mind. It was about fifteen minutes before dawn when I arrived and already I had that sense of urgency that I had to make sure I was in the right place with everything set up before the light became interesting. My first port of call was a small group of Silver Birch that has always provided me with a good focal point. I set up my trusty old Gitzo GT3541XLS tripod as I had done thousands of times before. With my Nikon D810 safely in place I proceeded to wait for the right light. I didn’t have to wait long for the rising sun to infuse with a little bit of light cloud and predicted mist. With a couple of pleasing shots in the bag I picked up my tripod and camera and wandered off to another area that has previously rewarded me with interesting compositions.

SC D810 3022.jpg

It was only a short distance so I kept the tripod extended with the camera still in place (something I keep telling my workshop participants NOT to do!). After a short while hunting around I found something that I thought might be worth a few frames and proceeded to open the tripod legs in readiness. Imagine my horror when one of the legs started to wobble and just flopped to the ground! Fortuitously I was still holding the tripod (or what was left of it!) with its precious cargo still perched on top! Still not certain what had occurred I was just about able to gently remove the camera from the Manfrotto 410 head and safely rest it on the ground. Closer inspection revealed that a large lump of metal had fallen off the tripod collar where the top leg should have been securely and permanently fixed! The first thing that crossed my mind was to recover the missing piece in the hope that I could somehow fix it. It turned out that the missing piece had literally crumbled into dozens of small pieces in the long grass. As it was only meant to be a quick local morning foray I decided to call it a day and pack everything away. Back at home I was able to look in more detail as to what had happened. The first thing I noted was the amount of fine powder still evident around the void where the leg should have been and the pitted grey surface inside. This led me to believe that it had somehow corroded and cracked through metal fatigue. My first thought was that salt water had been the culprit but this was at the very top and has never come in to direct contact with the sea. Thankfully I still had my old Manfrotto carbon fibre tripod which I could use until I could sort out a repair.

Gitzo spares were quoting £130.00 plus postage for the spare part so I began thinking as to whether it was going to be worth it? The tripod was eight years old and one of the other legs was showing similar signs of corrosion. I did in fact make a bodge repair over the coming days with a combination of a large amount of Araldite, gaffer tape and a jumbo jubilee clip! It seemed to be holding but I would never feel confident enough using it on an important trip.

Whilst all this was happening I also took to social media to have a bit of a moan and ask for any recommendations regarding what to replace it with? No sooner had I started to garner people’s opinions and suggestions that I received a private message from Mark Hoskins, Brand Manager at Benro asking if he could be of assistance? Quite coincidentally I had been admiring some of the Benro tripods at last years Photography Show with Pete Hyde who was also thinking of a change. I always like to try before I buy so Mark very kindly offered to send me a display model and would I like to choose one? After much deliberation I decided to give the Benro Mach3 TMA48CXL a go, the reason being that it seemed a similar spec to my old Gitzo GT3541 XLS.

When it arrived my first reaction was that it was a hefty piece of equipment! The feel of it though was one of quality, from the very attractive carbon fibre weave to the very hi-tech looking blue anodized column release and similar accents on the leg twist locks. As there was no head attached I quickly popped on my Manfrotto 410 which instantly increased the weight even more. As it was only on loan to me I thought it wise to try it out in my local woodland rather than give it a battering on the coast. One addition on my Gitzo, that I can’t do without, especially in woodland, were the leg spikes. Using a tripod with leaf litter underfoot is like placing your tripod on a springy mattress! Fortunately the Benro came supplied with a set of stainless steel spikes, albeit shorter than Gitzo’s long spikes but they seemed to work fine.

The immediate difference between the old and new was that the Benro leg sections were shorter meaning that I had to extend three leg sections instead of the normal two to get to the same eye level height as on my Gitzo (very rarely did I have to use the bottom leg sections on the XLS). This resulted in undoing nine rubber twist locks instead of my usual six. It did indeed surprise me that it really didn’t take that much longer to extend or retract the legs and after a short while became second nature. The leg sections on the TMA48CXL were also considerably thicker giving reassuring stability. Then there was the build quality. Gitzo have long held the reputation for using top quality materials and were built for professional reliability. It didn’t take me long to realise that they had met their match!

Inevitably the time came when I had to hand it back. By then though I had made the decision that Benro was going to supply my next tripod. I still had the niggling doubt though, as to whether the TMA48CXL was the right model for me. It was incredibly stable, however it did weigh more than my old Gitzo, and with it being more compact seemed to feel bulkier and even heavier so I was having a few doubts. After a quick conversation with Mark he suggested that the TMA38CL, the next model down, was probably the one to go for and he would arrange for one to be sent to my studio from their distribution centre together with their B2 ball head which would compliment it perfectly.

I didn’t have to wait long before the courier knocked on my door with a large oblong shaped box! As with most items of brand new photographic equipment it is always quite exiting to unbox it, something that people even make videos of! Unlike the loan model this brand new tripod also came complete with a very sturdy, padded carry bag which when opened revealed the object of desire encased in a neat, bright blue, drawstring dust bag. The tripod itself looked incredibly smart as per the loan model. Aside from the main item I discovered other goodies lurking in the side pockets. A set of short stainless steel spikes, a small spanner, two sizes of allen keys, a short column and a carry strap for the padded bag. Remembering back to when I took delivery of my Gitzo I think it only came with a dust bag and an allen key. Another plus (which was also on my loan model) was that one of the legs has a cold weather friendly foam leg warmer. Similarly when I unpacked the B2 ball head it just oozed quality.

Up to this point I was still in a quandary as to whether or not to attach my trusty 410 head or give the ball head a try? I’ve been using a Manfrotto 410 geared head for as long as I can remember (I’ve had three over the years!) and find the micro adjustments suit my style of composition. The only other ball head I’ve owned (and still do!) was the one that came supplied with my Benbo Trekker. There’s no quick release tripod plate, you just screw it into the bottom of your camera and with no friction control, it flops around like a babies head once released! The 410 head was duly transferred over, spikes screwed in and I was ready to go!

Anything new takes some getting used to but the loan model prepared me for some of the slight differences, more twist lock collars to turn for example. I also decided to keep the centre column in place for the time being, not that I ever use it fully extended (more advice I frequently give!) but sometimes it is quite handy when you need that extra couple of inches in height and don’t want to start fiddling with the length of the legs. I still might revert to the short column in due course as I have trapped my fingers more than once when closing the legs, it also makes it more convenient to carry around without the centre column. After a couple of long walks I rapidly became aware that the weight of the 410 head just didn’t seem to compliment the shorter, lighter, more compact TMA38CL, it was very top heavy! I eventually saw sense and replaced it with the B2 head and I must admit that it is now in perfect balance. Reverting to the ball head also meant that I could now try out an Arca Swiss fit ‘L’ bracket which I had viewed with envy over the years. Yes, I could have converted one of my 410 quick release plates to take an L bracket but it just seemed such a faff! Being able to revert back and forth from landscape to portrait without having any major adjustments was a revelation! At this point I am also going to admit to buying and fitting a new set of longer spikes, I found that the supplied shorter versions just weren’t able to pierce areas of dense leaf litter.

The past six months has been my busiest time of the year, Autumn and Winter; apart from a quick tighten of the leg screws on the odd occasion it has performed without fault. My latest trip to Glen Coe for a week certainly put it through its paces. In and out of rivers, icy lochs, snowdrifts and rocky scree combined with temperatures ranging from +10 to -10. The lighter weight of this tripod compared to the heavier Gitzo and 410 head certainly made the lengthier treks more comfortable too! Something I also never thought about before was the effect of tumbling a tripod in and out of a car boot would have. My Gitzo is covered in scratches and dents, the supplied padded bag that came with the Benro has been invaluable in protecting it and keeping it looking pristine! With my design/marketing hat on I’d just like to say that all these extra’s show that Benro are prepared to go that extra mile towards total customer satisfaction.

As those people that have attended some of my lectures can testify I can only but praise these wonderful pieces of photographic equipment and have no hesitation in recommending them to my many workshop participants. Whilst they also may not be the cheapest tripods on the market (much cheaper than the Gitzo though!) you certainly get what you pay for! No longer are they the poor cousins.

Thank you for taking the time to read my ramblings!